jmtiseo
The Peanut Gallery
jmtiseo, did your deal happen?
They shipped last week. Didn't think it was worth updating the thread as it will show that the item on eBay has been sold.
As mentioned, the reflectors are different between HID and halogen. I'm not sure what is different but from the looks of it the halogen has your traditional parabolic reflector where the HID reflecter is broken into what seems like 3 sections to direct the light.
It's really easy to spot the differences as described above. It's not too often you see someone knowingly sell halogen headlights as HID and vice versa. Unfortunately if someone doesn't know what they're looking for they either pay a pretty for something just isn't what it's supposed to be or they walk away with a steal of a deal like some of our members.

Good luck on the search. They seem to have been popping up more now. It seems as when I was looking I was lucky to find one every 3 weeks or so.