Same speedo gear I have on my Gen2. The tuner made about a 5% change in the tune when I went from 4.10s to 4.30s and retained the same 23-tooth black gear. The nice thing about Gen2s as you have noticed is that
our speedos are always accurate no matter what rear gear we have.

The funkiness comes when the tune has not been corrected for it and/or the wrong speedo gear is being used. I have heard that typically a 2 step change in the rear gear without addressing tuning or proper speedo gear will cause driveability concerns. And as stated, the black 23-tooth is the closest you're going to get. I have considered the SpeedCal and going back to the stock speedo gear just because the stock one is so much more durable. The 23-tooth has very thin teeth.