Has any proved it pings or makes the car run worse?
you need to be proved?
egr does alot of things..
increases economy
reduces pumping losses which increases economy and part throttle performance.
allow engine to tolerate more spark at light and medium throttle angles, which increases performance
it decreases combustion chamber temps, which increases the engines tolerance to spark knock, thus increasing performance
egr is inactive at WOT, so you lose ZERO performance.
most people think that its operation hurts performance when that couldnt be further from the truth in a modern efi controlled engine.
removing egr on a modern engine is HACKWORK at best and not recommended by "those in the know!
You will need a tune so they can pull some timing out of light and medium throttle levels, this will cost you performance and economy.
You will need a tune to turn off the check engine light
so in short, its gonna cost you performance in daily driving
its gonna cost you money to have a tune made which will further decrease your performance due to lost spark timing and increased pumping losses
its a lose, lose, lose scenario
now most tuners wont tell you this, because they know that IF they do, you will likely go find another tuner, and they will lose a SALE to some other tuner that will simply "tell you what you want to hear".
so...they WILL make your custom tune for you, regardless if your car goes FASTER or SLOWER.
since i have no vested interest either way, i can give you the info, without having to worry if you "find another tooner" as i dont care.
in the 70's and 80's egr worked all the time and hurt performance..
this isn't the 70's or 80's...