I don't think you're being too picky. I'd be the same way after paying that much for 2 center caps and them showing up like that. If you had paid $20 for the pair or something like that, it would be different, but then there would still the fact that he misled you, whether it was intentional or not. I've had stuff I wasn't completely satisfied with from E-bay before too, but, luckily, it was cheap stuff I picked up for around $10 or less, and everything worked, just maybe not exactly perfectly, so it wasn't worth it to me to make a fuss about it and go through the trouble to send it back and all that mess. At least E-Bay TRIES to make people be honest and make them accountable, but there's always those who just don't care about that or what kind of feedback/reputation they build on there as long as they're making a buck doing it.