A simple case of "Driver sucks". I used to run at the 1/8th mile track weekly as it was less than 3 miles from my house back when I lived in North Carolina. Back around 2001 I had an old beater Oldsmobile Ciera station wagon with a 3.3 V6. I used to run it after test and tune for the bracket drags because it was so slow and consistent.
One night during test and tune I lined up with a guy in a new 2001 SS Camaro with a 6 speed. The guy could not drive worth sh!t and I beat him not once but twice in the 1/8th mile by around 2 seconds. I was running something around a 10.3 at around 63, he was running 12.0-12.5 1/8th mile times spinning as he went.
That guy lost to me (twice), lost to a Fiero GT, a V6 Camaro and a 4 cylinder Honda Civic.
Now did I think I could go out and beat LS1 Camaros in a 3.3 160 HP station wagon? Of course not, even though it happened that night. Same here, give both cars equal drivers and this would not even be a race, but the earlier win would still be legit.