Hyelife..we have somewhat similiar tastes/paths.
I had a new 1992 318is (E36 Chassis) in 1992. Added M3 wheels and M3 bodykit to it around 1997. Also added the 3 pack VDO guage cluster under the climate control and a Jim Conforti chip. Totalled it in 1999.
Wanted a used 528i with Sport Package..but saw the NEW LS V6 with Sport for same price. Got the LS in 1999 and sold it in 2002 for the V8 LSE which I still have. And love. (handling and road feel/steering feel on this thing at 144k is still amazing)
Never forgot about my E36 love...so couple years back picked up a Arctic Silver 1999 E36 M3 Vert. It was in good condition and I spent a fair amount on it bringing it to excellent condition. Had all 5 wheels refurbished, I redid the entire interior with leatherseats.com, new OEM CD head unit, new glass headlamps with citylights, mildly smoked tails, corners, sidemarkers. New OEM mats. New OEM struts, shocks/shock reinforcement plates in back, Control Arms/Control Arm Bushings, Tie Rods, Ball joints, alignment. Literally got her in perfect, flawless running condition. Engine and (automatic) transmission strong and quick as new.
As GREAT as the auto transmission was in there(quick shifting..kept the revs during spirited driving, especially in "s" mode), I never could REALLY get over the E36 in anything other than a 5 speed manual. So, sold it to my sister last year who LOVES IT. It's her weekend toy.
I searched the market for another toy for myself and got another car that I admired for years: 2002 CLK55 AMG Convertible. 35k miles. Garage Kept. White exterior/black interior. All stock except for XM add on module and 17inch AMG wheels were replaced with 19 inch AMG wheels. Rest of the car? Absolutely flawless. 5.4 liter v8 with almost 400ft/lbs of torque. Admittedly its an auto..but it has the SelectShift type transmission..and it only came..in an auto. So no constant jealousy of manuals. lol And it too..like the M3..shifts perfectly. Both really, really put the LS transmission to complete and total shame.
Only take it out on nice occassional weekends and love that thing.
Plan to keep it for awhile..I think. However used SL55 AMG's (supercharged) are calling me. lol