i agree take the cover off it isnt much more work for a much cleaner job in the end. then you can wipe alll the metalic mud out of it because it will have it. i used royal purple posi gear oil with my 4:30 diff, they dont give the stuff away!
um, that would mean i didnt put it in my car, which would be bad news for the new owner. if you cant afford some measly gear oil i would hope you dont own a car. i didnt say you had to buy royal purple, traditional gear oil is cheap.
then use Right stuff gasket maker to reseal it