
|
Originally Posted by mike maluchnik
Rangel does this all the time. He skews it into a race issue,when it isn't. It's volunteer,nobody is forced into it. Rangel needs to look up the "volunteer" in the dictionary.
|
|
Originally Posted by 97silverlsc
I agree with Rangel, reinstate the draft. All you imperialistic hawks that want to take over oil fields or otherwise involve the US in unnecessary wars can help support the troops with the ultimate sacrifice--yourselves or your kids.
![]() |
|
Originally Posted by 97silverlsc
I agree with Rangel, reinstate the draft. All you imperialistic hawks that want to take over oil fields or otherwise involve the US in unnecessary wars can help support the troops with the ultimate sacrifice--yourselves or your kids.
![]() |
|
Originally Posted by 95DevilleNS
Considering all you said to be true, it still would be a lousy idea. The 'upper crust' will always have loopholes for themselves and their children. A draft would only guarantee a weaker military as people who do not want to serve will be forced to serve. A volunteer system (some cases aside) guarantee's soldiers that want to live a military lifestyle and want to fight.
|
|
Originally Posted by JohnnyBz00LS
While I agree the "upper crust" would maintain loopholes, I'm not sure if I buy the "volunteers guarantee a stronger army" connection. I don't think you'll find an enlisted person who'd argue that basic training and everything else done to build each person into the "Army of One" makes a much better person out of them. With a few isolated cases as an exception, in general one could easily argue that making every high-school grad go through boot camp not only provides just as strong as army (are we doubting the reformation capabilities of boot camp here??), but a better society overall by giving opportunities to many they would'nt have had the guts to persue otherwise, and forced the slackers of society to shape up and possibly become a better person. I'm suprised those who are so quick to blame today's problems on rap music, video games and designer clothes haven't instead blamed the lack of the draft for being at least partially to blame for the downfall of society.
|
|
Originally Posted by 97silverlsc
I agree with Rangel, reinstate the draft. All you imperialistic hawks that want to take over oil fields or otherwise involve the US in unnecessary wars can help support the troops with the ultimate sacrifice--yourselves or your kids.
![]() |
|
Originally Posted by 97silverlsc
I think the draft should be reinstated. Period. Arguments that it's not as good as a volunteer army are moot, the military has lowered their standards to accept racists, skinheads and felons because they're not meeting their quotas now. Their are a lot of people who are quick to jump on the war wagon who might not jump so quickly if it were their ass or their kids ass on the line.
![]() |
|
Originally Posted by 97silverlsc
I think the draft should be reinstated. Period. Arguments that it's not as good as a volunteer army are moot, the military has lowered their standards to accept racists, skinheads and felons because they're not meeting their quotas now. Their are a lot of people who are quick to jump on the war wagon who might not jump so quickly if it were their ass or their kids ass on the line.
![]() |
|
Originally Posted by 95DevilleNS
I see your point, but generally speaking, when someone forces 'you' to do something against your will do you generally just accept it and make the best out of it or do you rebel against it and fight the assimilation?
|
|
Originally Posted by pepperman
would you go into the Military if you got drafted?
|
|
Originally Posted by JLewisinSyr
I do not want the draft, I am a democrat, so I guess your logic is flawed in your post title.
Glad you demonstrate what ignorance you have towards politics. Rangel wants the draft, not democrats as a whole. In other words, correlation is not causation!!! Plain and simple! Oh, and I didn't read the entire thread, nor do I plan to, it seems all you like to post is Republican spew. |
|
Originally Posted by JohnnyBz00LS
Generally speaking, I think for most, it depends on if its for a noble cause or not. I believe if you took 100 "slackers of society" and put them through basic training, 80 will become good soldiers and better people. Another 15 won't make it through boot-camp and get rejected or quit, and the other 5 will be put into positions where they can do no harm. You still end up w/ a good % of "good soldiers" on the battle field.
Even then, way less than half of those drafted will be societal slackers. Contrast that with the military's lowered standards we have now............??? When I turned 18 I signed up for the selective service and was prepared to serve my country if called upon. It all comes down to this question: Is GW BuSh and the GOP war-hawks REALLY SERIOUS about waging this global war on terror or NOT? If they are, they are going to need significantly more servicemen to do it. |
| the military has lowered their standards to accept racists, skinheads and felons |
|
Originally Posted by mike maluchnik
How dare 97silverlsc say that our men in the service are degenerates !!! We have THE BEST trained and equiped army this earth has ever seen. These men are valiant and honorable. 97silverlsc dosen't have a clue. I wonder how our servicemen feel when a person like 97silverlsc provaricates about them. Everyone has the right to their opinions,pro-war or anti-war,that choice is what makes America the greatest country ever. That does not give the right to ANYONE to question the integrity of our armed services.
|
|
Originally Posted by 97silverlsc
If you want to get pissed save it for the idiot in chief that got us in the mess we're in now!!!
|
|
Originally Posted by pepperman
would you go into the Military if you got drafted?
|
|
Originally Posted by FreeFaller
Hey Phil...I was almost tempted to lash out at you...almost. But then I realized that I would just perpetuate the point you're trying to make.
Now, you live in NJ right. Well, I'm going to give you a Private Message next time I go to McGuire AFB/Ft. Dix...should be sometime after Christmas. I will escort you throughout the base and personnaly invite you to meet some of these people you are so quick to disparage. You will have a chance to speak to USAF, USA, USMC and USCG personnel and learn what type of people they really are. I know because I serve beside them every day and have for the past decade. I know what kind of people enlist in the military. The opinions of you and your articles aren't worth the paper they are printed on. |
|
Originally Posted by fossten
Phil admits he's 48 years old. That would make him approx. a teenager during VietNam. Makes sense. A "deaf ears" America-hating war protester from the 60's/70's would just about fit the bill of an angry person like him. Don't take any of his frothing at the mouth seriously. He's a lost cause. Heck, he still thinks that Rove is about to be indicted.
![]() |
|
Originally Posted by 97silverlsc
Fossie,
You can make like a hoover on my wingwang! Once again, you call for proof of a statement, articles backing the statement are posted and you respond by attacking the poster. My father and mother both served in WWII and I lost an uncle in WWII. I'm proud of their service. No, I didn't agree with Vietnam and I didn't then and don't agree now with us going into Iraq. And yes, I do love this country, but that doesn't mean I have to agree with everything it does. Take your self righteous Reporklican high and mighty, I know everything you know nothing attitude and stick it up your A**! It's people like you, especially ones in offices of power, that are screwing this country up! |
vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2008,
Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.
vB Easy Archive Final ©2000 - 2008
- Created by Stefan "Xenon" Kaeser